Mamma Mia!first premiered in July 2008, and it immediately became a cult classic.

With iconic stars such asMeryl Streep,Amanda Seyfried, andColin Firth, how could it not?

Fans were jumping out of their seats trying to decipher Sophie’s Seyfried’s character father.

Amanda Seyfried Mamma Mia! premeire

Instead, Sophie accepts that all three fathers-to-be are a part of her life.

What kind of ending is that?

It’s not surprising that there was an eventual sequel.

Cher and Meryl Streep interview

But its sequel, titledMamma Mia!

This time, audiences see through Donna’s past and her romances with the three fathers-to-be.

In the present, Donna is dead (so sad), and Sophie is struggling as a mother-to-be.

The sequel ends in the same fashion as the original film: never revealing Sophie’s true father.

Will fans ever get the answers they’re beenwaiting for since 2008?

A third Mamma Mia!

“I was meant to have been getting on with that, in my head, during these months.

But then I got hit with COVID fog,” she said in the interview.

I know Universal would like me to do it."

“So yeah, I wish there was aMamma Mia!

Fans can catch theMamma Mia!that started it all on Showtime, beginning on March 2.