While appearing alongside Peter Krause, formerly ofSix Feet Under, Coolidge looked back on the elaborate scheme.

“Quite a few years back, I did come to Kauai.

“I ended up meeting these two guys that were best friends, and I liked them both.

Jennifer Coolidge with curly hair

And so, I told them that I had an identical twin.

And I dated both guys for two weeks.”

“You know, when you’re younger, you could just about get away with anything.”

Jennifer Coolidge attends world premiere

Would Peter Krause fall for Jennifer Coolidge’s scheme?

In response, Krause said he would have bought into the plot on at least two separate occasions.

“Well, I’d have to find out which twin I liked best,” he joked.

“So, at least twice.”

“I would love to play Paulette again,” she said at the time.

“I don’t see anyone being able to replace her in that part,” Coolidge admitted.