FutureBacheloretteClare Crawleyfirst met Juan Pablo Galavis during his season ofThe Bachelorin 2014.
She earned the first one-on-one date of the season, a sledding and snowball fight.
The date ended with a private concert (viaLife & Style).
She ended up sticking it out the entire season and ended up being his first runner-up.
However, there were many bumpy roads throughout their season and moments of miscommunication thatBachelorfans will never forget.
That moment stirred up controversy for the rest of the season.
In a long personal essay onPeople, Juan Pablo wrote, “I definitely made a mistake.
The next day I felt guilty because Clare got more time with me than the other women.
I regretted giving Clare the extra time.
“That he doesn’t know me and some sexual thing I don’t want to repeat.
It was insulting and it was offensive.”
He didn’t propose to her though.
First, Juan Pablo had to break things off with Clare.
When he eliminated her, Clare delivered an epic speech that cemented her as a favorite amongstBachelorfans.
“I lost respect for you because I’ll tell you what.
I thought I knew what kinda man you were,” she toldThe Bachelor(viaABC).
“What you just made me go through?
I would never want my children having a father like you.”
Juan Pablo told the cameras, “I’m so glad I didn’t pick her!”
“It’s gonna be INTERESTING seeing HER get hit on by KIDS on their 20s…
He also toldLife & Style, “I never had any bad blood with her.
I did what I had to do, which was pick who I felt was The One.
